Printing with sound

Researchers use acoustic forces to print droplets that couldn't be printed before

By Leah Burrows
August 31, 2018

Research Highlight: Acoustophoretic Printing: Printing Soft Materials with Sound

Researchers from the Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences (SEAS) have developed a new printing method that uses soundwaves to control the size of liquid droplets independent of fluid viscosity with an unprecedented range of composition and viscosity. This approach could greatly broaden the types of liquids that can be printed drop-on-demand, and could finally enable the manufacturing of many new biopharmaceuticals, cosmetics, and food and expand the possibilities of optical and conductive materials.

The research is published in Science Advances open doi in new window open pdf in new window.

An explanatory video of Acoustophoretic Printing. Credits: Daniele Foresti, Lori K. Sanders, Jennifer A. Lewis, Harvard University.

"By harnessing acoustic forces, we have created a new technology that enables myriad materials to be printed in a drop-on-demand manner," said Jennifer Lewis, the Hansjorg Wyss Professor of Biologically Inspired Engineering at the Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences (SEAS) and the senior author of the paper.

Lewis is also a Core Faculty Member at the Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering, and the Jianming Yu Professor of Arts and Sciences at Harvard.

Liquid droplets are used in many applications from printing ink on paper to creating microcapsules for drug delivery. Inkjet printing is the most common technique used to pattern liquid droplets, but it’s only suitable for liquids that are roughly 10 times more viscous than water. Yet many fluids of interest to researchers are far more viscous. For example, biopolymer and cell-laden solutions, which are vital for biopharmaceuticals and bioprinting, are at least 100 times more viscous than water. Some sugar-based biopolymers could be as viscous as honey, which is 25,000 times more viscous than water.

Honey is a prototypical example for viscous fluid, being 25 thousand times more viscous (i.e. thicker) than water. Acoustophoretic printing enables droplet formation of any material, generating the possibly tiniest single drop of a tiny honey jar. Video captured with a high speed camera (colorized). (Image courtesy of Daniele Foresti, Lori K. Sanders, Jennifer A. Lewis, Harvard University)

The viscosity of these fluids also changes dramatically with temperature and composition, makes it ever more difficult to optimize printing parameters to control droplet sizes.

"Our goal was to take viscosity out of the picture by developing a printing system that is independent from the material properties of the fluid," said Daniele Foresti, first author of the paper, the Branco Weiss Fellow and Research Associate in Materials Science and Mechanical Engineering at SEAS and the Wyss Institute.

To do that, the researchers turned to acoustic waves.

Thanks to gravity, any liquid can drip—from water dripping out of a faucet to the century-long pitch drop experiment. With gravity alone, droplet size remains large and drop rate difficult to control. Pitch, which has a viscosity roughly 200 billion times that of water, forms a single drop per decade.

To enhance drop formation, the research team relies on generating sound waves. These pressure waves have been typically used to defy gravity, as in the case of acoustic levitation. Now, the researchers are using them to assist gravity, dubbing this new technique acoustophoretic printing.

By controlling the target position, the ejected droplets can be carefully deposited and patterned anywhere. In this example, honey drops are patterned on a glass substrate. Since the honey is so viscous (i.e. thick), the droplets take quite some time to wet the glass! (Image courtesy of Daniele Foresti, Jennifer A. Lewis, Harvard University)

The idea is to generate an acoustic field that literally detaches tiny droplets from the nozzle, much like picking apples from a tree

The researchers built a subwavelength acoustic resonator that can generate a highly confined acoustic field resulting in a pulling force exceeding 100 times the normal gravitation forces (1 G) at the tip of the printer nozzle — that’s more than four times the gravitational force on the surface of the sun.

This controllable force pulls each droplet off of the nozzle when it reaches a specific size and ejects it towards the printing target. The higher the amplitude of the soundwaves, the smaller the droplet size, irrespective of the viscosity of the fluid.

"The idea is to generate an acoustic field that literally detaches tiny droplets from the nozzle, much like picking apples from a tree," said Foresti.

The researchers tested the process on a wide range of materials from honey to stem-cell inks, biopolymers, optical resins and, even, liquid metals. Importantly, sound waves don’t travel through the droplet, making the method safe to use even with sensitive biological cargo, such as living cells or proteins.

To eject droplets, acoustophoretic printing utilizes airborne ultrasounds - virtually material independent. Even liquid metal can be easily printed! This particular liquid metal forms a solid shell when in contact with the atmosphere, and this particular property makes it easy to pile drops one on top of another. (Image courtesy of Daniele Foresti, Jennifer A. Lewis, Harvard University.)

"Our technology should have immediate impact on the pharmaceutical industry," said Lewis. "However, we believe that this will become an important platform for multiple industries."

"This is an exquisite and impactful example of the breadth and reach of collaborative research," said Dan Finotello, director of NSF's MRSEC program. "The authors have developed a new printing platform using acoustic-forces, which, unlike in other methods, are material-independent and thus offer tremendous printing versatility. The application space is limitless."

Harvard's Office of Technology Development has protected the intellectual property associated with this project, and is exploring commercialization opportunities.

Authorship, funding, disclosures

This research was co-authored by Katharina Kroll, Robert Amissah, Francesco Sillani, Kimberly Homan, and Dimos Poulikakos. It was funded by Society in Science through the Branco Weiss Fellowship, the National Science Foundation through Harvard MRSEC grant DMR-1420570, the GETTYLAB, and the Blavatnik Biomedical Accelerator at Harvard University.